Truthful Tuesday

Ugh. You guys. I'm so stumped on what to get my dad for Chanukah. Which starts today! Yikes! Fortunately, we usually just lump our Chanukah and Christmas gift giving all into one day so I have some time still. But not that much!
I like to think that I do a decent job of gifting things I know the recipient will love. Friends often come to me for gift suggestions, so I have evidence to back up this claim. Some examples that you guys have to promise not to tell (seriously, these peeps don't read the blog, so make sure they don't find out!): Step Mom has been wanting to get back to riding. I currently don't have a safe beast for her, so I'm getting her a couple lessons and a pair of Regal boots. My mom is a HUGE Hillary Clinton fan, so she's getting a signed copy of HRC's book. (Plus a bunch of other stuff cause she's my momma). My little brother who lives in the wilderness without electricity? Hammock.
But. There's one guy that I just have the hardest time finding gifts for. My dad! The man has everything he could ever want. And his taste is far and above my budget. He doesn't have much in the way of hobbies other than sport fishing. Let me tell you, there is nothing in my price range to get him for THAT.

So what am I going to do you ask? So far I got him a case of his favorite nostalgia candy:

Seriously. He loves these things. But that's not exactly a significant gift. So probably he's going to get the old standby that he gets EVERY holiday (we're talking Chanukah, birthday, AND Father's Day). Yep. 2 Polo shirts and a sweater. So original.
Do you guys have any suggestions for the man who has literally everything? He doesn't drink at all and doesn't golf if that's helpful (I know, not at all).
Do you have anyone really hard to shop for on your list? What do you end up doing for him/her?